EDITORIAL
- Share via
A year ago, we complained that the California Coastal Commission --
which regulates beach-side development and watches over delicate habitats
-- was overstepping its mission by ordering Newport Beach resident
Rodolphe Streichenberger to remove an artificial reef he had built next
to the Balboa Pier.
The reef, which is made of rubber tires, plastic jugs and PVC piping,
has become a refuge of sorts for the marine life that exists in our
increasingly hostile offshore environment.
Despite the apparent good caused by the reef, the commission planned
to go ahead with its order, but was halted by a lawsuit filed by
Streichenberger in January 2000. Late last month we found out what the
potentially disastrous results of his lawsuit are. In a ruling on the
case, the commission was declared unconstitutional by a superior court
judge who said it is not accountable to the state government or the
voters.
Following the decision, Streichenberger applauded the ruling and
called the commission “tyrannic.” We wish we could share his enthusiasm
for what is potentially, and perhaps literally, an earth-shattering
decision.
Since it was set up in 1972, the commission has been a strong advocate
for protecting our precious coasts and oceanfront waterways. Now, thanks
to this wide-ranging ruling, any number of commission decisions --
including recent orders to clean up Crystal Cove, for instance -- could
be challenged. Then, that earth-shattering noise you will hear is a
five-star hotel where the Crystal Cove cottages now stand.
Commission lawyers, of course, plan to appeal the ruling and are
urging the courts not to put the decision to work before an appeals court
makes another decision.
Now, the commission is not perfect, even environmentalists acknowledge
that. Giving them free reign to halt any construction is clearly the
other side of the coin of unrestrained development that is intolerable.
And perhaps this lawsuit will act as the impetus for needed, thoughtful
change. But simply getting rid of the commission would be an
environmental disaster that we cannot afford.
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.